All Star Superman
Okay, this is weird but mostly entertaining. Lovely art and fluid storytelling. But boy did I feel like a whole lot of references were flying high, high above my head.
Simone's run on Wonder Woman
Decent story, good characterisation, awesome action. Simone totally can tell epic stories and frequently pushed my FUCK YEAH! button by showing what a motherfucking badass Diana (and various other characters are). The stories themselves feel a bit uneven and were frequently a bit confusing, but they were events and action packed (especially in contrast with Rucka's slower pacing). Flip side, the antagonist were frequently much less interesting (and often a bit cringey) than in Rucka's run. Art was very good too.