Had I been involved in the original discussion, I'd explained why I think those comments were stupid but here, knowing that etrangere has heard the same arguments again and again, well, I just assumed she knew why I thought they were stupid and didn't need to explain myself. Also, I didn't expect people from the board to show up here. It's a matter of context. But she's done a better job of explaining myself than I could so...
About Ran's commentary, I was talking about criticism and parody value, not about what he was saying about fanfic. I admit it was more my frustration at being forced to read bad criticism than anything else.
no subject
Date: 18 July 2008 06:19 pm (UTC)Also, I didn't expect people from the board to show up here. It's a matter of context.
But she's done a better job of explaining myself than I could so...
About Ran's commentary, I was talking about criticism and parody value, not about what he was saying about fanfic. I admit it was more my frustration at being forced to read bad criticism than anything else.